How to create a college list

Building your college list is one of the most important—and most personal—parts of the application process. The right list should reflect your goals, values, and the kind of environment where you’ll thrive.

This guide from the Onward Scholars Program walks you through the tools and tips that make it easier to build a well-rounded, best-fit college list tailored to your unique strengths and interests.

SECTION 01

Finding the Right Fit

A well-balanced college list includes schools that fit you—not just your GPA. That means thinking beyond academics and asking yourself:

  • Do I want a big school or a small one?

  • What kind of campus culture do I want?

  • How far from home am I willing to go?

  • Do I qualify for need-based or merit aid?

  • What academic programs or support services matter most to me?

Your final list should include:

  • Likely schools where your stats are above the average admitted profile

  • Match schools where you're solidly in range

  • Reach schools that may be more competitive—but still worth aiming for